The Psychology of Actions
CS408 Human Computer Interaction Lecture 11 provides an in-depth analysis of the psychology of human action, mental model formulation, and human error classification in interactive computing environments. Grounded in cognitive psychology, Kenneth Craik first proposed in 1943 that the human mind constructs small-scale mental models of external reality to anticipate events, test potential actions, and react safely to novel situations. Donald Norman expanded this concept within HCI, defining a mental model as the internal representation users form of themselves, interactive systems, and operational environments through experience, instruction, and training. Complementing this, Philip Johnson-Laird demonstrated that mental models function as dynamic structural simulations that can be mentally executed to predict state outcomes, distinguishing them from static mental images. However, human mental models are inherently incomplete, unstable, easily confusable, and frequently anchored in unscientific folk theories. A classic illustration is the thermostat: many users subscribe to the valve theory, operating under the flawed more-is-more assumption that setting the thermostat to an extreme temperature will heat a room faster, whereas thermostats function as binary on-off switches governed by threshold sensors. Similar erroneous mental models explain why users repeatedly press elevator buttons or strike frozen computer peripherals. When poorly designed systems provide inadequate feedback, users frequently internalize failure, resulting in self-blame, a conspiracy of silence, and learned helplessness. Norman characterizes this systemic design deficiency as taught helplessness, wherein confusing interface cues induce unjustified feelings of technical incompetence. To explain human-system interaction mechanics, Norman formulated the Seven Stages of Action model, bifurcated into execution and evaluation cycles anchored by user goals. The execution cycle progresses through forming a goal, formulating an intention to act, specifying an action sequence, and physically executing the action upon the world. The evaluation cycle comprises perceiving the state of the world, interpreting perceptual sensory input, and evaluating the interpreted outcome against initial goals. Interfaces present two major cognitive barriers: the Gulf of Execution, representing the psychological distance between user intentions and system-allowable actions, and the Gulf of Evaluation, reflecting the mental effort required to assess whether system feedback confirms goal fulfillment. Finally, the lecture establishes Norman error taxonomy, distinguishing deliberate mistakes from unintentional slips. Mistakes occur during conscious planning when users form incorrect intentions based on faulty mental models, such as dragging a hard drive icon to the trash to erase its contents. Conversely, slips represent execution failures in well-learned automatic behavior, such as typographical errors, capture slips, and mode errors. This academic analysis supports Virtual University students preparing for CS408 midterm examinations, solved past papers by Moaaz and Waqar Siddhu, and competitive assessment MCQs.
No questions available yet.
There are currently no examination questions published for The Psychology of Actions. Explore other curriculum units or build a custom quiz with the practice builder.